Car finance complaints: what lender responses mean under the FCA scheme

Lenders have started responding to car finance commission complaints under rules set by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). Some complainants have received letters or emails, and others have heard nothing. This article sets out the deadlines lenders are working to, the main types of response, and what each one indicates.
Under the FCA's rules, lenders must tell complainants by set dates if they consider that nothing is owed under the redress scheme. Receiving no rejection can therefore be a positive sign. It does not confirm that compensation is due.
Lender notification deadlines
The deadline depends on when the finance agreement started and when the complaint was made.
| Agreement start date | On or after 1 April 2014 | Before 1 April 2014 | Any date |
|---|---|---|---|
| Complaint made | By 30 June 2026 | By 31 August 2026 | On or after 1 September 2026 |
| Lender notification due | 18 November 2026 | 18 January 2027 | Within 5 months of the complaint |
The 7-week grace period
The FCA has said it will not take enforcement action against a lender that needs more time, provided the complainant is told within 7 weeks of the relevant scheme deadline. In practice, notifications for the November group may arrive as late as early January 2027, and for the January group as late as early March 2027. A lack of contact shortly after a deadline is therefore not conclusive.
Exceptions to the deadlines
Lenders are not bound by these dates where they consider a complaint to be out of time under the usual complaint-handling rules. More detail on time limits is set out in changes to car finance claim deadlines. Where a complaint also covers issues outside the scheme, the lender is still expected to give an outcome on that part.
Types of lender response
1. Acknowledgement only
An acknowledgement confirms the complaint has been recorded and falls to be assessed under the scheme. While the legal challenge to the scheme continues, lenders are not required to calculate compensation, so long periods without further contact are expected.
2. Not owed, or outside the scheme
This response means the lender has assessed the agreement against the FCA's rules and does not consider that redress is due. Lenders must follow the FCA's methodology closely, so these decisions are often accurate, although errors are possible. The process after a rejection is covered in more detail in car finance claim rejected: what happens next.
A decision of this kind can be challenged in three ways:
A written request to the lender to review its decision.
A referral to the Financial Ombudsman Service, which is free to use.
A court claim, where the case is judged against the law rather than the scheme rules. This route usually involves a solicitor and carries additional cost and risk.
3. Commission arrangement confirmed
Confirmation of a commission arrangement indicates that redress could be due. Arrangements such as a discretionary commission arrangement (DCA) are central to the scheme. Whether anything is owed, and how much, depends on the details of the agreement and the result of the legal challenge. Lenders are expected to keep complainants updated.
4. Early settlement offer
Some lenders have chosen to settle complaints ahead of the scheme. Barclays Partner Finance is making early offers to some customers whose complaints it acknowledged on or before 1 October 2026. The FCA expects any early offer to be no lower than the amount due under the scheme rules, and lenders must show how the figure was calculated. A fuller breakdown is available in car finance settlement offers explained.
Accepting an early offer is a full and final settlement:
| If the scheme later... | Becomes more generous | Becomes less generous or is overturned | Stays the same |
|---|---|---|---|
| Effect on an accepted offer | The difference cannot be claimed | The amount paid does not have to be returned | Redress has been received sooner |
Offers carry a response window. Barclays Partner Finance allows one month. There is no obligation to accept.
5. No acknowledgement
Where no acknowledgement has been received, the complaint may not have reached the lender. Common causes include a message that was never sent and replies filtered into junk or spam folders.
Common causes of delay
- Dual representation. Where two firms are handling the same complaint, it can slow progress and lead to two sets of fees. See dual representation in car finance claims.
- Duplicate complaints. A second complaint about an agreement that has already been acknowledged adds to the paperwork without speeding up the outcome.
- Out-of-date contact details. Lenders contact complainants using the details held on file, so a change of address, name or phone number can lead to missed correspondence. Existing Mis-sold Expert customers can update their details through the client portal.
Making a complaint
Complaints can still be made while the scheme is partly suspended, and lenders continue to record and acknowledge them. The scheme covers car finance agreements, including PCP and HP, taken out between 2007 and November 2024. An overview of how these products work is available in how car finance really works in the UK.
There are free routes available. A complaint can be made directly to the lender, and then to the Financial Ombudsman Service if needed, free of charge or via the FCA’s free to use redress scheme. Alternatively, a claims management company such as Mis-sold Expert can handle the complaint, including correspondence and follow-up with the lender.
You can claim without using a claims management company, to your finance provider and then to Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS), for free. The FCA has introduced a free consumer redress scheme.
*Free check refers to the soft-credit check to identify your vehicle finance agreements.
**The FCA currently estimates that most individuals will potentially receive an average of £829 in compensation per agreement. We find on average 2 car finance agreements per client, giving a potential claim value of £1,658. See: https://www.fca.org.uk/news/statements/fca-confirms-motor-finance-redress-scheme.
***If you cancel outside the cooling off period cancellation charges may apply at a rate of £80+VAT, per hour. We charge a fee between 18-36% (including VAT) for a successful claim.




